1
Season 1 / Re: GCDL Round 2 - T0X1C vs. WDF
« on: October 17, 2008, 02:27:21 pm »
Red_Aces:
Sorry at work so I can't always pin point and address every bit of detail. Yes, you're right the +30 raw damage does not benefit the images but the +30 from AGI does convert to damage and I'm pretty sure the 30 IAS does too. Will need to double check that during the weekend. Thanks for the correction.
Radiance:
FYI the 35 AoE damage doesn't stack either. Now here's the good news..
-Theoretically, assuming 2 illusions are next you you, the TB gets...
[(AoE Burn/sec*) + (Hero +Dmg) = Total ] (35) + (60) = 95 unmitigated damage ONLY in a 400 radius!
*It would be amazing IF everyone would just come dance around you in melee range wondering what those sparklies are? Fairies? I hope so -_-
Butterfly:
-Theoretically, assuming 2 illusions are next you you, the TB gets...
[(30 AGI=30 DMG: 30*55%= 16.5 x 2) + (Hero +Dmg + AGI:Dmg) = Total ] (33) + (30 + 30) = 93* unmitigated damage even at MAX range!
*I'm not even considering the base 30% Increased attack speed bonus, Armor & the IAS received from the AGI multiplier.. lol
1.What in the world makes you say images don't need damage when 55%x2 = 110% Damage = +1 hero!!!
TB isn't meant to tank all 5 heroes, he needs to kill fast before they get close and disable him. Please stop referring to games that take over 1-2 hours to finish where you end up filling all 6 slots with Lvl 4-5 items. Tournament games (especially US and Euro) are fast paced and very intense, you'd be lucky if you manage to secure more than 1 Lvl 4 item!
You must be forgetting about Cleaving? Physical Melee & Range AoE damage (Medusa, Juggernaut etc.)? If you want to talk about "Survivability".. Butterfly gives an amazing 30% evasion compared to the measly 8% you get from Radiance which does not even stack!
So here's my argument;
Radiance can be a very solid item on TB, IF you have all the time in the world to farm the other items unnoticed then ride in with your 5 'L33t Imb4' items to solo all 5 and finish it off?!?! Well that wasn't the case as we witnessed in this game yar? TB was basically non-existent!!! Radiance is nothing but a Neutral grinder. After you get a few more damage items? What does it provide you with for all that cash you spent on it? A non-stackable evasion, short AoE burn that doesn't do jack when in Meta form, and +60 damage only on main hero. Lolfactor!
Where as Butter will give you just as good farming potential and you can do some amazing damage when needed to kill/push, plus the weapon scales with the other items you get like EoS, Buriz, 2x butter etc.
If you got the time, there was a video up sometime ago on some DotA forum. Portal or Allstars? I'm guessing. In order to put the famous "Rad vs Butter" argument to rest, they pit 2 players on a 1v1 MM. TB with Radiance/EoS (RE) vs TB with Butter/EoS (BE) + 2 conjured images for each.
(RE) farmed faster, but after a few minutes when (BE) finished off (RE) 1v1 even faster it wasn't even funny.
Anyways my lunch break is over so got to run off plus I've got nothing else to say on this topic.
I would like to wish T0X1C & G|hut good luck for tonight. Will be awaiting the replays. Btw anyone know what has happened to Mumble and His reviews?
Cheers,
F
Quote
oh btw images dont get the 30 IAS or the +30 damage
Sorry at work so I can't always pin point and address every bit of detail. Yes, you're right the +30 raw damage does not benefit the images but the +30 from AGI does convert to damage and I'm pretty sure the 30 IAS does too. Will need to double check that during the weekend. Thanks for the correction.
Quote
thats about 15 damage in addition to the base damage. thats nothing compared to the 35 aoe damage given by the radiance.
Radiance:
FYI the 35 AoE damage doesn't stack either. Now here's the good news..
-Theoretically, assuming 2 illusions are next you you, the TB gets...
[(AoE Burn/sec*) + (Hero +Dmg) = Total ] (35) + (60) = 95 unmitigated damage ONLY in a 400 radius!
*It would be amazing IF everyone would just come dance around you in melee range wondering what those sparklies are? Fairies? I hope so -_-
Butterfly:
-Theoretically, assuming 2 illusions are next you you, the TB gets...
[(30 AGI=30 DMG: 30*55%= 16.5 x 2) + (Hero +Dmg + AGI:Dmg) = Total ] (33) + (30 + 30) = 93* unmitigated damage even at MAX range!
*I'm not even considering the base 30% Increased attack speed bonus, Armor & the IAS received from the AGI multiplier.. lol
Quote
the images dont need damage. wat they need is hp so butter/radiance will not really matter against aoe damage.
1.What in the world makes you say images don't need damage when 55%x2 = 110% Damage = +1 hero!!!
TB isn't meant to tank all 5 heroes, he needs to kill fast before they get close and disable him. Please stop referring to games that take over 1-2 hours to finish where you end up filling all 6 slots with Lvl 4-5 items. Tournament games (especially US and Euro) are fast paced and very intense, you'd be lucky if you manage to secure more than 1 Lvl 4 item!
You must be forgetting about Cleaving? Physical Melee & Range AoE damage (Medusa, Juggernaut etc.)? If you want to talk about "Survivability".. Butterfly gives an amazing 30% evasion compared to the measly 8% you get from Radiance which does not even stack!
So here's my argument;
Radiance can be a very solid item on TB, IF you have all the time in the world to farm the other items unnoticed then ride in with your 5 'L33t Imb4' items to solo all 5 and finish it off?!?! Well that wasn't the case as we witnessed in this game yar? TB was basically non-existent!!! Radiance is nothing but a Neutral grinder. After you get a few more damage items? What does it provide you with for all that cash you spent on it? A non-stackable evasion, short AoE burn that doesn't do jack when in Meta form, and +60 damage only on main hero. Lolfactor!
Where as Butter will give you just as good farming potential and you can do some amazing damage when needed to kill/push, plus the weapon scales with the other items you get like EoS, Buriz, 2x butter etc.
If you got the time, there was a video up sometime ago on some DotA forum. Portal or Allstars? I'm guessing. In order to put the famous "Rad vs Butter" argument to rest, they pit 2 players on a 1v1 MM. TB with Radiance/EoS (RE) vs TB with Butter/EoS (BE) + 2 conjured images for each.
(RE) farmed faster, but after a few minutes when (BE) finished off (RE) 1v1 even faster it wasn't even funny.
Anyways my lunch break is over so got to run off plus I've got nothing else to say on this topic.
I would like to wish T0X1C & G|hut good luck for tonight. Will be awaiting the replays. Btw anyone know what has happened to Mumble and His reviews?

Cheers,
F